Controls: show

Topic

Comments:

[log in] or [register] to leave a comment for this topic.


Go to: all topics

Go to: treetops

Options: show

Contact:

mail@publiccommons.ca

Website:

[home] [about] [help] [policies] [legal disclaimer]

Subsites:
Members:

[profiles] [forum]

Who makes the rules?

Cover page Topic details

Who makes the rules?

Setup: 17-Jun-2012 by Belinda Cole [1229]

• Who gets to make the rules for our public amenities? Why does it matter? Our elected officials must account to constituents for their decisions. What about government officials who make more and more decisions in our public commons?

In our experiences, bureaucracies take on rule-making roles in a number of different circumstances. Sometimes, our elected representatives - at the municipal, provincial and federal levels - grant decision-making powers to government staff.

Other times, staff act on the mistaken or possibly mistaken understanding that they have rule-making powers.

What discussion and participation do we want to have in decisions about how our local public facilities are run and maintained?

A shift of decision-making powers from our elected officials to bureaucracies often has significant and far-reaching effects on civic life, democracy and public spending. With one's elected official, we, as citizens, have immediate, ongoing access to express both our appreciation and our dissatisfaction with his or her decisions. At election time, we can choose to support our representative, or, seek someone who better represents our views and priorities .

Unlike elected officials, staff decision-makers within bureaucracies are often: hard to identify or reach, frequently have no connection to - or familiarity with - the neighbourhoods for which they make decisions, nor any personal accountability for their decisions.

Staff decision-makers are rarely required to respond to community concerns or questions, attend public forums, or provide information outside of a formal freedom of information process, nor can citizens vote to keep or replace staff representatives.

Staff are often influenced, courted and lobbied by industry advocates with a direct interest in the rules and requirements of running public facilities.

Other “remedies” or avenues of complaint often require time-consuming and onerous steps, often with little response or change. For example, a city staff member of an occupational health and safety who makes a fundamental, last minute change to a community rink design in the name of "safety" has no obligation to explain or account for his decision....

"Public safety" was also the motivation behind one city staff member's new rule forbidding the long-time practice of fishing on the waterfront. One public official - reacting to "about half a dozen complaints ... in recent years" has the power to make a new rule affecting an estimated 10,000 anglers, all across the city City council rescinded the fishing ban, but has not addressed the underlying problem - that city staff seem not to have the legal authority to make these kinds of far-reaching rules, in the first place.

Who makes the rules?

Setup: 17-Jun-2012 by Belinda Cole [1229]

• Who gets to make the rules for our public amenities? Why does it matter? Our elected officials must account to constituents for their decisions. What about government officials who make more and more decisions in our public commons?

-- Details --
Sorted by: ·custom order· (if any), title (asc). Page 1 of 1 (items 1-4 of 4)

·1· OHSA rink changes

Description: A fundamental, 11th-hour design change was made to Wallace Rink - based on city staff's reading of the Occupational Health and Safety Act. Neighbhours, involved in the design asked for an explanation, but none was ever provided.

Part of: OHSA Who makes the rules?

Date: 19-Jun-2010 [114]

·2· City approves reduced fees for sports fields  The Star article, June 12, 2012

Part of: Permits Who makes the rules?

Date: 17-Jun-2012 direct link (StarCityApprovesReducedFeesForSportsFields120612.pdf) [1231]

·3· Sudden fishing ban on waterfront  The Star article, June 11, 2012

Part of: Who makes the rules?

Date: 17-Jun-2012 direct link (StarSuddenFishingBanOnWaterfront110612.pdf) [1230]

Lifesaving society

Description: Offers various courses

Part of: First Aid City Staff Training Requirements Wading pool safety Who makes the rules?

Date: 15-Jul-2012 direct link [1567]

page 1 of 1 (items 1-4 of 4) per page: